Tavel:
I dont recall ever saying to run the system with NO fluid?
Am I missing something here. LOL?
And Hydrolock:
Well, Not to say your idea of turning the motor over to pump fluid is a completely bad Idea, but how do you KNOW you got it all out?
Well you dont.
Hence my method.
Ideally:
Remove the old crap.. as much as you can.. Refill.
Remove the air by turning the steering Lock to Lock while the engine is at idle.
Shut it off.
Drain again as best you can. Refill.
One extra step. And you KNOW its all clean.
So yeah, you might save a moment of time with your method.. But you dont do as good of a job!
My method uses LESS fluid.. Not more.
You can SEE the results using air because when nothing more comes out during a drain, that means you got most of it. (the first time around).
Your way works, but why go through the hassle of taking out fuses (fuelpump AND Ignition unless you want to flood the engine and put raw gas in the catalytic converter), and then putting wear on your starter and battery at the same time?
The starter might crank the engine close to 600RPM, but the powersteering pump isnt moving even that fast.. And the starter is designed for short Bursts upto 10 seconds with a 2 minute cool down.
THAT IS NOT for this procedure!
It will overheat the starter in a hurry.
And for those with little experience doing this kind of thing, why tell them to crank the motor? HOW long do they need to crank? What guarantee is there that its ALL going to come out? What if you get an airbubble during filling while cranking and the fluid isnt coming out and there STILL is old crap in there even using your method?
Sure its Anal to say this.. But you are telling me that you SAVE time?
Its not worth the risk.
Its still messy no matter what way you look at it to drain.
Dude, thats not only a waste of time, its hard on parts you arent even needing to monkey with!
I dont think telling people to crank for an Inordinate amount of time, and removing fuses is the answer.
A newbie needs a simpler understanding.
What good is extra speed when you dont do the job right?
You STILL have to remove lines and you still have to drain it.
When using the Air method, you DO save time.
IF you dont have a Compressor, then you will have to drain as best you can, refill, and drain again. Your method is NOT a surefire way of accurately removing all the old fluid and replacing it, without creating more wear and tear and having to risk damage to other components.
Im not saying in "theory" your idea is all bad. Seriously.. Id do it myself if there werent other repercussions, but I think of the method as a bit too "lazy" for my tastes and experience.
You loose pressure if you dont keep filling the reservoir during the crank procedure you spoke of. I like your thoughts in that regard, and yes.. that does work and is good advice.. For the Powersteering pump. Not the Starter, Nor the Battery!
You still need to do the Lock to Lock method.. to get air out, and to make sure fluid is flowing through the Powersteering gearbox (or rack).
You can start the engine ONLY to MIX the new fluid with whatever is left of the old.. Then, Drain again.. And refill. It WONT mix correctly unless you use enough fluid to get the old out right?
So, Get as much of the OLD stuff out FIRST, then add new stuff, and then drain, and add again. It will get more of the old stuff out using the Powersteering pump RUNNING at IDLE (which is going much faster) and it will act as a washing machine for the lines, (as they will be under full pressure) and whats left of the old stuff will be suspended in the new fluid.
Then, draining once more, and refilling you know its clean.
Whats wrong with doing it right?