So both brake lights in my Rogue were burnt out, confirmed visually by inspecting the filaments in the bulbs. Looked up online replacement and went to auto parts store. The Sylvania website, AdvanceAuto, and AutoZone all list both the Sylvania 7443 ZEVO bulb and the cheaper Sylvania 7443 LED bulb as compatible with the 2011 Rogue. The ZEVO was not in stock so I bought the cheaper bulb. When I returned home and installed I found that the bulb would only work for either the tail light or the brake light depending on which direction you installed the bulb. I called Sylvania tech support, when they looked up their notes on the 2011 Nissan Rogue they told me that the cheaper LED bulb would not work on the 2011 Rogue, even though their website says it is a direct replacement. They said only Version 2 of the ZEVO bulb will work on the 2011 Nissan Rogue. I asked how I identify a version 2 vs a version 1 and was told that it had been a while since version 1 and that I should not find them on store shelves anymore. Based on the faded color on boxes in the auto parts stores, I'm not sure if this was a good answer or not.
So I went on Amazon and bought a Phillips Ultinon LED bulb that in the description says it is a direct replacement for any car with a 7443 bulb... Unfortunately it has the same issue as the cheaper Sylvania bulb, so I have two sets of bulbs to return. I've found a store that has the ZEVO in stock. Will report back whether or not the ZEVO really works.