Thanks for the reply PapaCap. I went to the same auto parts store that I called and just found it on the shelf for $5.
I used the tips in a different thread to remove the switch from the door and take it apart. First I thoroughly sprayed the circuit board with the contact cleaner and let it dry. Then I pried the cap off the toggle switch for the drivers side window and sprayed that out as well. (that one was really dusty) Those caps don't come off easily but I stuck a very small flathead screwdriver (like the size found in an eyeglass kit) on one side of it and then used another one on the other side to pry it off without breaking the plastic pieces holding it on.
When I pulled the cap off the switch I noticed a very small white plastic piece with two prongs on it (also plastic) that appears to be what moves back and forth and makes contact with the metal piices to make the window go up and down. One of these prongs is black and nearly flat - i'm guessing that this is why the window only works intermittently - maybe just from use over time? A plastic piece on the metal contacts doesn't seem like the best choice....after 117,000 miles it's I might wear out too.
I decided to first get the window in the up position so that if I ended up doing some kind of irreperable damage to the piece that I would at least be warm on the drive to the mechanic. So I reassembled the switch (with the exception of the cap on the main window toggle) and plugged it back in. Pressing down on the two metal prongs with a pencil made the window go up instantly.

!!!
Now my question is - does anyone know if it's possible to just replace the small plastic pronged piece or is it necessary to replace the entire switch?
If it's not possible to replace just that piece are there any suggestions for a substitute for this piece? I'd really prefer not to buy a $100 part solely for the plastic piece that would probably run about 5 cents on it's own.
Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated!
Jen